Having trouble deciding

[jojo760]

I am going to purchase a new handgun in the coming week. I thought I would ask what you guys think about the three I am thinking about.

Springfield Armory TRP
Kimber Warrior II
Sig P220

Which do you guys think I should get?

[Aluisious]

IMO, Kimber Warrior

EDIT I have good experience with Kimber, and I believe the TRP is very spendy.

I don't like Sigs personally. Most any 1911 would beat out a Sig in my book. DA/SA triggers with no cock n lock option don't appeal to me.

[markymark]

My ranking would be:

P220
TRP - #2 only because of the aggressive checkering
Kimber

[brassburnz]

I have a weakness for 1911's, so they would top my list. Although I have two Kimbers, I like the fact the Springfield doesn't have a firing pin lock.

Randy
NRA Life Member

[cseabass]

you cant go wrong with a TRP. i just ordered a warrior 2, ill give a range report when i get it(itll be roughly 5 weeks though). if i didnt get the warrior 2, i would have gotten a TRP operator.

[saki302]

I own al three. If I had to pick one-

TRP Operator/Kimber series I match
then P220
Then regular TRP/Kimber

-Dave

[berg]

It really depends on what you want the gun for. Do you want a range gun or a defensive gun? The DA/SA is something I prefer in a defensive gun, plus the rail on the P220R is nice for Home Defense.

BTW you can get a SIG P220 with an SA trigger. Cocked and locked is good to go with a Sig.

[Ratters]

See if you can hold each. The TRP is a sweet piece but I don't like the way Springfields feel in the hand, the 20lpi checkering is kinda rough for me too. Kimbers fit my hand well. Sigs feel great too, but I prefer single actions.

[cseabass]

one thing about the warrior is the grips tend to REALLY bite hard into your palm, i can tell im gonna need to file them down when i get it.

[RT13]

P220R or ST.

Then the Kimber.

[zefflyn]

They're all the same. Get a S&W 625.

[cnyankee]

il give you the reply when i post a decision thread about which gun i should get.......get 1 of each

[oghl888]

My choice would be:

1) TRP
2) 220
3) Kimber

S&W 1911's are very well made, too. I have 4 of them including Performance Center versions.