Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Which Replacement Recoil Spring?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Spitfire75
    Member
    • Dec 2005
    • 285

    Which Replacement Recoil Spring?

    Hey everyone...I've put around 3500 rounds through my Springfield PX9109L and I'm thinking about buying a new recoil spring for her. I typically shoot a lot of Federal AE 230gr., but I occasionally shoot 230gr. Winchester SXTs and Speer Gold Dots. Which recoil spring would you recommend? Wilson? Wolff? And which weight/resistance? 16lb? 18lb? Thanks in advance!
    "If they want to live in the Stone Ages, we can surely send them back there."
    - Mr. Burns
    Spitfire75
  • #2
    xrMike
    Calguns Addict
    • Feb 2006
    • 7841

    A 16lb recoil spring is standard for 5-inch 1911s in .45ACP, and should work fine with 230grain ammo.

    Last time I replaced mine, I went with this one from Wolf. Also comes with a replacement firing pin spring:



    This spring is also working fine with my reloads, which are 200grain lead semi-wadcutters, loaded with 5.0 grains of Winchester 231.
    Last edited by xrMike; 11-21-2006, 1:54 PM.

    Comment

    • #3
      Spitfire75
      Member
      • Dec 2005
      • 285

      Thanks Mike. I didn't even think about replacing my firing pin spring.
      "If they want to live in the Stone Ages, we can surely send them back there."
      - Mr. Burns
      Spitfire75

      Comment

      • #4
        TMC
        Senior Member
        • Oct 2005
        • 2348

        Try a 12lb spring, you'll be amazed how much nicer the guns shoots. Don't worry about hurtng the gun, you won't. I have thousands of rounds through my 40 cal 1911 with a 10lb spring without a hint of wear.
        where are my pistol mags?

        Comment

        • #5
          xrMike
          Calguns Addict
          • Feb 2006
          • 7841

          Originally posted by TMC
          Try a 12lb spring, you'll be amazed how much nicer the guns shoots. Don't worry about hurtng the gun, you won't. I have thousands of rounds through my 40 cal 1911 with a 10lb spring without a hint of wear.
          What does "nicer" mean? Is the recoil softer somehow? Depending on your answer I may be willing to try something different too, just to see what happens.

          Comment

          • #6
            Spitfire75
            Member
            • Dec 2005
            • 285

            Wouldn't a lighter spring equate to more felt recoil? It would seem like a lighter spring would allow the slide to move with less resistance, causing more of a kick. The springs are cheap...I guess I could try a 12lb and a 16lb. spring. Something to think about, hmmmmm...

            "If they want to live in the Stone Ages, we can surely send them back there."
            - Mr. Burns
            Spitfire75

            Comment

            • #7
              TMC
              Senior Member
              • Oct 2005
              • 2348

              Originally posted by xrMike
              What does "nicer" mean? Is the recoil softer somehow? Depending on your answer I may be willing to try something different too, just to see what happens.
              The gun will recover from recoil better and feel softer. Think about what happens when the gun cycles with a heavy spring, the slide pushing aginst that spring pushes your hand more, when it travels forward it has lots of energy from the heavy spring and forces the muzzle down as it slams closed.

              With a light spring there is less pushing aginst you and less slide energy when it closes.

              Try it out and see for yourself. Spings are chaep. Bring a few different springs to the range and shoot them back to back. I use 10's in my 1911's.
              where are my pistol mags?

              Comment

              • #8
                TMC
                Senior Member
                • Oct 2005
                • 2348

                Originally posted by Spitfire75
                Wouldn't a lighter spring equate to more felt recoil? It would seem like a lighter spring would allow the slide to move with less resistance, causing more of a kick. The springs are cheap...I guess I could try a 12lb and a 16lb. spring. Something to think about, hmmmmm...

                Most of the recoil you feel happens before the slide unlocks and there's nothing you can do about that. Muzzle flip and some felt recoil is from the slide movement and the jet of gas coming out of the barrel. You want the slide to move with as little upset to the frame and you.

                What I'm talking about is how the guns it shoots/feels overall, especially when you shoot quick shots and watch the sights, its much better with lighter spring. The gun will recoil and come right back to where it was much better. And don't worry about reliability, if you gun is built right it will run with light springs first round to the last.
                where are my pistol mags?

                Comment

                • #9
                  bu-bye
                  Veteran Member
                  • Oct 2005
                  • 2835

                  I don't know about going with a lighter spring . If its a match gun or just a range queen then by all means but if its a gun you use for home defense then I would stick with stock weight springs. If you shoot a bunch of high power defense rounds your lugs are going to take a beating. Also if you have to use a mag with stiff springs you might have feed issues on the first couple rounds. Maybe its just me but I would not change a thing. I have only gone with a lighter spring (12lbs) on a competition gun and that was to shoot very lightly charged reloads. For a defense 1911 I would not drop below a 14lbs spring.
                  "Calling an illegal alien a "undocumented worker" is like calling the drug dealer hanging around outside your kid's school an "unlicensed pharmacist."

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Kruzr
                    In Memoriam
                    • Oct 2005
                    • 1751

                    Do not use lighter springs in a .45 1911 unless you are shooting lighter loads. Bullseye shooters who shoot bunny "loads" go down to 10 lb. recoil springs.

                    If you are going to shoot factory 230 gr. ammo, or ammo that makes major power factor, then stick to the 16# recoil spring for a Gov't. 1911. You will batter the gun with springs that are too light.

                    You may also want to think about changing the springs a bit sooner. I change springs at about 2500 rounds in my Gov't size 1911's.

                    Wolff springs are a good choice and are the springs used by many manufacturers. Buy direct from Wolff at www.gunsprings.com
                    Last edited by Kruzr; 11-21-2006, 4:37 PM.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Spitfire75
                      Member
                      • Dec 2005
                      • 285

                      Yeah, battering the frame/lugs is what I was concerned about with using lighter springs. I guess I'll just go with good old reliable 16# springs. Thanks guys!
                      "If they want to live in the Stone Ages, we can surely send them back there."
                      - Mr. Burns
                      Spitfire75

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        snacks
                        Senior Member
                        • Jan 2006
                        • 939

                        i would recommend using a sixteen pund or 18 pounder. I shoot IDPA and have found that the Wolff 16lb variable rate is just right for 230 grain ammo. Tracks real nice and i can see my sights real well during recoil. When i shoot a lighter load such as a 200 or 185 grain i switch to a 14.5 wolff variable rate spring. With custom loaded loads for IPSC i would run a twelve pounder.

                        If you use 230 grain a 16 variable rate spring feels real nice. Some of my buddies prefer the 18 pounder. I would suggest you try a couple since springs are cheap as mentioned earlier.

                        It has been suggested that with lighter springs a shok buff is recommended but i have seen people tear up shok buffs in less that 200 rounds.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          elsolo
                          Veteran Member
                          • Jan 2006
                          • 4798

                          "felt recoil" and "softer shooting" are obviously quite personal and subjective things, with a lot of variables.

                          That said, virtually all competetive shooters run lighter recoil springs, even when shooting full power loads. I highly recommend any interested shooter try varying spring rates and see what works best for them.

                          If defensive use is your intent, you must function test your setup reguardless of whether or not the replacement is "factory rated" as that is no guarantee of proper function with your gun/grip/ammo/etc.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            Kruzr
                            In Memoriam
                            • Oct 2005
                            • 1751

                            That said, virtually all competetive shooters run lighter recoil springs, even when shooting full power loads. I highly recommend any interested shooter try varying spring rates and see what works best for them.
                            It depends on the set-up of the gun. If they shoot full power ammo with lighter springs, they are getting more muzzle flip and more recoil transmitted to the shooter. Most competitive shooters tailor the load to make the power factor needed if it's applicable. If there is no PF, then you find the lightest, accurate load and pick the spring to suit.

                            If you are going to shoot 230 gr. ball ammo, like the 1911 was originally designed for, you should stick with the springs intended for that. For most Gov't models it's 16#. For some semi-customs, the makers recommend 18.5# variable.
                            Last edited by Kruzr; 11-21-2006, 7:32 PM.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              elsolo
                              Veteran Member
                              • Jan 2006
                              • 4798

                              Originally posted by Kruzr
                              It depends on the set-up of the gun. If they shoot full power ammo with lighter springs, they are getting more muzzle flip and more recoil transmitted to the shooter. Most competitive shooters tailor the load to make the power factor needed if it's applicable. If there is no PF, then you find the lightest, accurate load and pick the spring to suit.

                              If you are going to shoot 230 gr. ball ammo, like the 1911 was originally designed for, you should stick with the springs intended for that. For most Gov't models it's 16#. For some semi-customs, the makers recommend 18.5# variable.
                              How light depends on the ammo of course, but no shooters I know run a recoil spring that is heavier than factory, even those that run 190pf hardball.

                              You are going to get the exact same amount of recoil, but it will feel different (pushy vs. snappy). Too much spring and the front of the slide nosedives, if you prefer a pushy impulse instead of a snappy one, that may be one result of running a heavier spring.

                              This is really a personal preference issue, I advocate each individual trying out for themselves rather than take advice from a random internet poster about exactly what is the perfect weight spring for their gun.

                              This is a question that does not have "one right answer for all"

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1