I plan to purchase my first handgun in a week or two. It is either a glock or XD in 9mm. Which one shoots better out of the box? I have shot the glock 17 at the ranges a few times and i love it. But i also hear a lot of good stuffs about the XD. I went to turners; the SS XD is not that cheaper than a 9mm glock. $499 compare to $529. This gun basically for home defense and range... thanks
Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
XD vs. Glock
Collapse
X
-
Nothing against Glocks, but, for me personally, they don't fit my hand. Go to a range that rents guns, shoot all they have, go to another range, shoot all they have, shoot any and all you can and then make up your mind. As another member pointed out "handguns are like underwear, you can't have another tell you what to wear." Personally, I like Sigs and Berettas, but they may not fit you.Originally posted by cadetcode3:
I plan to purchase my first handgun in a week or two. It is either a glock or XD in 9mm. Which one shoots better out of the box? I have shot the glock 17 at the ranges a few times and i love it. But i also hear a lot of good stuffs about the XD. I went to turners; the SS XD is not that cheaper than a 9mm glock. $499 compare to $529. This gun basically for home defense and range... thankssigpicComment
-
Gun to gun, imho, the glock is way better...
however, the real question is which do you grip better, and shoot better. (as the grips and grip to barel angle is very diff. between the two).
I love the glock and could not imagine a cheap knock off, with an added grip safety, and a lesser finish. Heck, i remember when the HS2000 sold here for under $200, (1999-2001), then when Springfield Armory became the exclusive importer, they put their name on it, and more than doubled the price, thus the XD was born, still sold under the HS2000 name in other countries. BTW, its made in Croatia.PRK -----> Henderson - Las Vegas area.
Not a single regret!Comment
-
I own both and either choice is great. The Glock's finish is much easier to look after and I find it easier to get holsters etc for that gun.
The advice above on buying the one that you shoot best is good. They have slightly different characters and I find I shoot the Glock better at full size and the XD better at subcompact size but it might be the opposite for you.Comment
-
Tough to go wrong either way. Glock finish will be better. Most say the XD feels better in the hand, but i've always felt that's more of a training issue. Given some time, the Glock grip angle is easy to get used to. Not a big fan of the grip safety or the loaded chamber and cocked indicator on the XD. Adds un-needed complexity to the gun. XD does have ambi mag release, which is nice if you are left handed. You already said you like the G17 and the price advantage that made the HS2000 such a deal is no longer so big. You see where i'm going.Comment
-
As others have mentioned, I would suggest you go to your local range and try out other options before you limit yourself to just the Glock and XD.
I have owned a Glock G34 and currently own a XD9Tactical. I found the glock was not for me. Nothing mechanically wrong, but the grip was so different from everything else that I owned that after shooting the glock I would have to readjust to shoot my other guns. Other 9mm I own are P226, P225, Beretta 92G Elite 2, CZ75B, and SA 1911. They are all excellent choices with the CZ closest to your price range and extremely worthy of consideration. There's a plethora of good 9mms out there.**********************************************
- Official Red Ryder Carbine-Action Two-Hundred-Shot Range Model Air Rifle.
- WTB: Nerf N-Strike Longshot CS-6Comment
-
I'm not sure where you live, and I hate sending you there, but L.A. Gun Club usually has almost every gun you'd ever care to try as a rental.
Yes, the place degenerated into a dick-filled hell-hole over the years, and I haven't been back in at least 5-6 years, but for a beginner who wants to try all kinds of different guns, they have it.
The Firing Line may have a Glock 17 for rent, but I doubt they have the XD.
If you've already shot the G17 and like it, I'd definitely buy that over the XD, but that's just me. The two pistols I shoot best are the Sig 220, and Glock 17/19. I haven't taken my USP Elite to the range yet, and my P7M8 is too nice and became a safe-queen
-DaveComment
-
I live in Orange County, Westminster. I visit glocktalk and xdtalk almost everyday to read stuffs about those two guns. . This gun is for home defense, at the range and future use in the police academy. At first I thought the XD would be a lot cheaper than the glock, but i guess not. I heard the bad points for the xd are finish problems and failures to feed. I think i will go with Glock then. I have a few questions?
What is the law for transporting firearm to the shooting range?
Does anyone have membership at the Firing Line? I plan to get one there. How is the service?
Thanks...Comment
-
Well... quick differences check.
1) XD has a grip safety
2) Grip angle on XD is usually more user friendly.
3) Glocks finish is tough! XD finish is the weakest finish on a handgun. Extreme differences in durability
4) Glock grip angle usually makes the gun point high for many shooter, myself included
5) Finger groove on Gen 3 Glocks
6) Glocks have accessories galore
7) I find the Glock good looking, or at least many leagues better than the HS2000/XD
8) Big difference in trigger feel, Glocks trigger takes time getting used to. But have very short reset.
Honestly, between the two I'd go for a compact Glock (G19/23/32). But, that didn't work after I tried it out so I'm not gonna own either of them anymore.
For membership to the Firingline, ask Kruzr. He'll help you with any questions you may have, since I believe he works there.~RichardComment
-
Both will serve you well-- just shoot and choose.
BTW-- I have been to the LA Gun Club a lot in the last year or so and found the employees to be really nice--surprisingly so. Maybe they have got it together since you were their last.Comment
-
Given the majority of people who work at gunshops and shooting ranges that I frequent lack any in-depth knowledge of guns and have the unusual ability to manufacture opinionated incorrect answers to most questions, I don't think that speaks too well of GlockOriginally posted by markymark:
if it makes any difference, i've noticed the majority of people who work at gunshops and shooting ranges (that i frequent) carry glocks.
-hankoTrue wealth is time. Time to enjoy life.
Life's journey is not to arrive safely in a well preserved body, but rather to slide in sideways, totally worn out, shouting "holy schit...what a ride"!!
Heaven goes by favor. If it went by merit, you would stay out and your dog would go in. Mark Twain
A man's soul can be judged by the way he treats his dog. Charles DoranComment
-
I've seen a few often release the slide stop and let the slide slam forward (without a dummy round) instead of easing it forwardOriginally posted by -hanko:
Given the majority of people who work at gunshops and shooting ranges that I frequent lack any in-depth knowledge of guns and have the unusual ability to manufacture opinionated incorrect answers to most questions, I don't think that speaks too well of Glock
-hanko
"Want me to punch-i-size your face, for free?" ~ RFComment
-
Glock, indestructable, not a problem.Originally posted by kalibear:
I've seen a few often release the slide stop and let the slide slam forward (without a dummy round) instead of easing it forward
PRK -----> Henderson - Las Vegas area.
Not a single regret!Comment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,902
Posts: 25,177,329
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,395
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 31042 users online. 140 members and 30902 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.

Comment