Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jlh95811
    Veteran Member
    • Sep 2008
    • 2833

    ...

    ...
    Last edited by jlh95811; 08-24-2010, 1:26 AM.
    "people shouldnt be bumping sold stuff. but it is hard to herd cats." - rkt88edmo
  • #2
    JeffM
    Veteran Member
    • Sep 2007
    • 4359

    Why? If you are a member here with any sort of history you will earn a reputation with the other members without any of that crap.

    Comment

    • #3
      jlh95811
      Veteran Member
      • Sep 2008
      • 2833

      Originally posted by JeffM
      Why? If you are a member here with any sort of history you will earn a reputation with the other members without any of that crap.
      Oh, yeah. My fault. You are totally right. I simply forgot that I knew all the active members here. I have had enough contact with each one to form an opinion on them individually.
      Active Members: 15,473
      Seriously though...
      It sure would be nice to see what members who have had contact with an individual or seen their posts thinks of them. It would be especially helpful for new members.
      "people shouldnt be bumping sold stuff. but it is hard to herd cats." - rkt88edmo

      Comment

      • #4
        JeffM
        Veteran Member
        • Sep 2007
        • 4359

        Originally posted by jlh95811
        Oh, yeah. My fault. You are totally right. I simply forgot that I knew all the active members here. I have had enough contact with each one to form an opinion on them individually.
        Active Members: 15,473
        Seriously though...
        It sure would be nice to see what members who have had contact with an individual or seen their posts thinks of them. It would be especially helpful for new members.
        So you're going to trust the opinions of all those members you don't know, to give you an accurate representation of all the other members you don't know?

        Comment

        • #5
          JeffM
          Veteran Member
          • Sep 2007
          • 4359

          I'm obviously not the most personable person that contributes to the board, but does that mean the information I give is not valid or accurate? What is the reputation rating based on?

          I can see it turning into a love-fest for the TAN type people here that just want to *.
          Last edited by Librarian; 08-23-2010, 8:48 AM. Reason: Let's not diminish our own reputations with crudity.

          Comment

          • #6
            jlh95811
            Veteran Member
            • Sep 2008
            • 2833

            Originally posted by JeffM
            So you're going to trust the opinions of all those members you don't know, to give you an accurate representation of all the other members you don't know?
            Fairly accurate, yes. Of course I'm not going to think bad about a member if they have 1 bad rep given out of 5 reps given; But if they happen to have like 20 bads out of 100 total then I will avoid them.
            Once enough votes have been dealt out you will start to see that a general consensus will grow; Good or bad.
            "people shouldnt be bumping sold stuff. but it is hard to herd cats." - rkt88edmo

            Comment

            • #7
              JeffM
              Veteran Member
              • Sep 2007
              • 4359

              Originally posted by jlh95811
              Fairly accurate, yes. Of course I'm not going to think bad about a member if they have 1 bad rep given out of 5 reps given; But if they happen to have like 20 bads out of 100 total then I will avoid them.
              Once enough votes have been dealt out you will start to see that a general consensus will grow; Good or bad.
              Maybe that's where we differ.

              I've never liked the idea of "consensus".

              Comment

              • #8
                jlh95811
                Veteran Member
                • Sep 2008
                • 2833

                Originally posted by JeffM
                I'm obviously not the most personable person that contributes to the board, but does that mean the information I give is not valid or accurate? What is the reputation rating based on? ...
                I figure it would be based on any and all interactions.
                Quality of posts in serious threads
                Ability to take a joke in non serious threads
                Communication Skills
                Helpfulness in answering questions
                Spreading of FUD or lack thereof
                etc. etc.
                "people shouldnt be bumping sold stuff. but it is hard to herd cats." - rkt88edmo

                Comment

                • #9
                  JeffM
                  Veteran Member
                  • Sep 2007
                  • 4359

                  Originally posted by jlh95811
                  I figure it would be based on any and all interactions.
                  Quality of posts in serious threads
                  Ability to take a joke in non serious threads
                  Communication Skills
                  Helpfulness in answering questions
                  Spreading of FUD or lack thereof
                  etc. etc.
                  I'd see it turning into a popularity contest. There's plenty of * going on here already. I don't think we should make it that easy.
                  Last edited by Librarian; 08-23-2010, 8:48 AM. Reason: Let's not diminish our own reputations with crudity.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    jlh95811
                    Veteran Member
                    • Sep 2008
                    • 2833

                    Popularity won't really help those who are rated poorly.
                    "people shouldnt be bumping sold stuff. but it is hard to herd cats." - rkt88edmo

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      D.M.C.
                      Member
                      • Jun 2008
                      • 180

                      I have seen grudges and back-scratching reduce rep systems to a laughingstock within weeks on other forums. It sounds nice on paper, but in reality it's just a really, really, bad idea. Seriously, I applaud your efforts to provide areas of positive feedback and change for the CGF, I think it's a great channeling of energy, but I do think maybe you are shooting for "too-much, too-fast" and should look carefully at what is working right now, instead of necessarily proposing sweeping changes. It's really the same as our popular government situation what with people wanting new laws to feel good about instituting change, rather than getting grimy and boring with enforcing existing laws and policies.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        jlh95811
                        Veteran Member
                        • Sep 2008
                        • 2833

                        Originally posted by D.M.C.
                        I have seen grudges and back-scratching reduce rep systems to a laughingstock within weeks on other forums. It sounds nice on paper, but in reality it's just a really, really, bad idea. Seriously, I applaud your efforts to provide areas of positive feedback and change for the CGF, I think it's a great channeling of energy, but I do think maybe you are shooting for "too-much, too-fast" and should look carefully at what is working right now, instead of necessarily proposing sweeping changes. It's really the same as our popular government situation what with people wanting new laws to feel good about instituting change, rather than getting grimy and boring with enforcing existing laws and policies.
                        Point taken.
                        I've been kicking the idea of a member rating system around in my head and on this forum. I saw this and thought it's essentially what I'm talking about. Though it might cause mods to work more due to folks disputing ratings as retaliatory.
                        I do not intend to push hard on this issue. I do intend to keep throwing up the 'Bump Button' and the splitting of Private Firearms Sales into Handguns and Long Guns as long as they are both getting favorable votes.
                        My biggest complaint though...
                        I've gotten NOT ONE response about ANY of these issues. It's kinda sad really. I think those two are important but they are just being avoided.
                        I'm starting to think the powers that be here just will not consider any changes no matter how popular they may be.
                        "people shouldnt be bumping sold stuff. but it is hard to herd cats." - rkt88edmo

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Librarian
                          Admin and Poltergeist
                          CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                          • Oct 2005
                          • 44698

                          Originally posted by jlh95811
                          Point taken.

                          My biggest complaint though...
                          I've gotten NOT ONE response about ANY of these issues. It's kinda sad really. I think those two are important but they are just being avoided.
                          I'm starting to think the powers that be here just will not consider any changes no matter how popular they may be.
                          If a decision is made on the things you have proposed, you'll see the result. In the meanwhile, not all things get discussed in public.
                          ARCHIVED Calguns Foundation Wiki here: http://web.archive.org/web/201908310...itle=Main_Page

                          Frozen in 2015, it is falling out of date and I can no longer edit the content. But much of it is still good!

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            yzErnie
                            CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
                            CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                            • Mar 2007
                            • 6310

                            Like DMC, I have seen this used on other forums I frequent and it has utimately resulted in the removal of the rating system. Popularity, grudges and as JeffM said, richard fornication ended up overwhelming the true intent of the rating system. I think anyone who is on this site more than 10 minutes a day pretty much knows who is who.

                            For me personally, I'd rather use the extra time it would take to rate others to browse the forums.
                            The satisfaction of a job well done is to be the one who has done it

                            Originally posted by RazoE
                            I don't feel a thing when some cop gets ghosted.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              jlh95811
                              Veteran Member
                              • Sep 2008
                              • 2833

                              Originally posted by Librarian
                              If a decision is made on the things you have proposed, you'll see the result. In the meanwhile, not all things get discussed in public.
                              I can understand that. I just wish someone would let me know they are considering it and what conclusion is reached. Otherwise I feel like I'm still fighting for the issue to be noticed.
                              "people shouldnt be bumping sold stuff. but it is hard to herd cats." - rkt88edmo

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1