Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

itrader feedback rules

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • HK4113
    Senior Member
    • Dec 2008
    • 1296

    itrader feedback rules

    These are the current rules.

    iTrader ratings. Negative feedback should be reserved for transactions where one party has lost either money or goods, or the delivered product is substantially different than advertised. Positive feedback is appropriate for a transaction with good communications between they parties involved and that completes in a timely manner. Neutral feedback is for everything else, including transactions which are not completed. Use the comment section to describe why you gave the rating you did. Retaliatory feedback is not tolerated and should be reported to a moderator. See Rule #15 regarding Marketplace Disputes.
    Recently I left negative feedback for a buyer because I drove down to the ffl in his area and he stood me up. I took the day off work to do this, so this cost with gas added up to $100 dollars which is a lot for a college student.

    I have since been informed that negative feedback can only be left if you are out money via a fraudulent check or counterfeit money or something else of the sort.

    I propose that we either amend these rules to allow for negative feedback for being stood up when an agreement was made, or amending the wording of the rules so that everyone is aware of what the "definition" of out of money really means.
  • #2
    Hott <3 Mess
    Junior Member
    • Aug 2010
    • 85

    That really sucks, I dont know why that wouldnt qualify for a negative feedback. Driving extremely far out of my way to be stood up would really piss me off. Did you eventually get the gun? Did the guy answer the phone when you called him?

    Comment

    • #3
      freonr22
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Dec 2008
      • 12955

      maybe an additonal; FLake rating? reall neutral does not influence me one way or another, hence the name... Ilike the flke rating system adder?
      sigpic
      Originally posted by dantodd
      We will win. We are right. We will never stop fighting.
      Originally posted by bwiese
      They don't believe it's possible, but then Alison didn't believe there'd be 350K - 400K OLLs in CA either.
      Originally posted by louisianagirl
      Our fate is ours alone to decide as long as we remain armed heavily enough to dictate it.

      Comment

      • #4
        beemaze
        Senior Member
        • Apr 2009
        • 1981

        Looks like you should have left Neutral feedback to the "no show."

        He left you retaliatory feedback which is also "not tolerated." Report the problem to a moderator and get it sorted out that way.

        I've performed many a transaction here with only one or two flakes. I left one negative for an individual who decided to up the price before we could meet and ended up selling to the higher bidder. I reported the offender to the mods who suspended his account after reading the offender's PM's asking for a higher price..

        Live and learn....

        The 2nd Amendment - The Original Homeland Security


        WTB Colt Woodsman's, WWI/II 1911's, Walthers: P4 or P38 / IV (German or French), PP Super .380, PPK (German or French), TP, TPH (German only), S&W 547 9mm, Any DA .22 Magnum revolver. Colt .22 Diamondbacks, Courier, Banker's Spl.

        sigpic
        FREE NRA FREEDOM ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP - CLICK BELOW
        https://www.nrahq.org/FreedomAssoc/default.asp

        Comment

        • #5
          HK4113
          Senior Member
          • Dec 2008
          • 1296

          Originally posted by Hott <3 Mess
          That really sucks, I dont know why that wouldnt qualify for a negative feedback. Driving extremely far out of my way to be stood up would really piss me off. Did you eventually get the gun? Did the guy answer the phone when you called him?
          I had previously thought it would count as negative feedback, but apparently I was wrong. Believe me I still am pissed about it, and I was the seller on this transaction. The guy didnt have a phone and never contacted me in any way to tell me he couldn't make it.

          Originally posted by freonr22
          maybe an additonal; FLake rating? reall neutral does not influence me one way or another, hence the name... Ilike the flke rating system adder?
          A flake rating would be great. I agree we need something a little higher than neutral, especially if you drive a considerable distance to meet up and you end up getting stood up.

          Originally posted by beemaze
          Looks like you should have left Neutral feedback to the "no show."

          He left you retaliatory feedback which is also "not tolerated." Report the problem to a moderator and get it sorted out that way.

          I've performed many a transaction here with only one or two flakes. I left one negative for an individual who decided to up the price before we could meet and ended up selling to the higher bidder. I reported the offender to the mods who suspended his account after reading the offender's PM's asking for a higher price..

          Live and learn....
          It was my understanding that neutral is is when the gun never exchanges hands and when you have not lost any money. I took a day off of work and drove a round trip of 120 miles to meet this guy. I am definitely out money.I have contacted the mods to get my retaliatory feedback taken off.

          I have since confirmed with a mod this guy has multiple accounts so he just uses another one if he gets bad feedback.

          Comment

          • #6
            XYZ
            Calguns Addict
            • Jan 2010
            • 5481

            Originally posted by HK4113
            I have since confirmed with a mod this guy has multiple accounts so he just uses another one if he gets bad feedback.
            This is against the rules. He should have all but one of his accounts banned. You already outed him in the OT lounge with your other thread, do you know his other handles?
            sigpic
            NRA Endowment Member

            Comment

            • #7
              Kestryll
              Head Janitor
              • Oct 2005
              • 21617

              Your iTrader has been corrected.

              Per the rules:
              Negative feedback should be reserved for transactions where one party has lost either money or goods, or the delivered product is substantially different than advertised.

              Loss of money in gas or time lost from work is both different and tricky.

              How far does someone have to drive before it constitutes a loss?
              25 miles? 50? 10?
              What if they're on a motorcycle?
              What about an F-350?
              Quantifying that means either setting a specific mileage range or dollar amount which can vary greatly based on traffic and/or vehicle.
              It's just not feasible without having to micromanage every transaction and I know no one wants that any more than we do.

              As for time lost from work, to be honest that's a choice you made and trying to hold someone else accountable for that decision really doesn't work.

              Neutral feedback is definitely warranted in this case.

              As for dupe accounts, the newer of the two has already been banned.
              NRA Benefactor Life Member / CRPA Life Member / SAF Life Member
              Calguns.net, LLC. - Owner.
              The California Rifle & Pistol Assoc. - Director.
              DONATE TO NRA-ILA, CRPA AND CRPAF NOW!
              Opinions posted in this account are my own and unless specifically stated as such are not the approved position of Calguns.net or CRPA.

              Comment

              Working...
              UA-8071174-1