Miller v. Bonta 9th Ckt "assault weapons": Held for Duncan result 1-26-24

[riderr]

I am sure Benitez very carefully chose the dates. It will be the Independence Day in exactly 31 day since this decision. Tell me it was a coincidence.

[riderr]

So, when can I throw a pistol grip on my AR?

Provided CA doesn't appeal, you may legally do it on the 4th of July. Well, we all know CA will appeal and ultimately win it in en-banc

[ar15barrels]

Amy "RAW"s have F-ing bullet buttons and are still limited to 10 round SMFH.....

News flash:
Your RAW's can use mags over 10 rounds.
The 10 round restriction only applies to fixed magazine guns which are NOT RAW's.

[sonofeugene]

I've got a nice pistol grip to throw on my gun if it becomes legal. Takes about 2 minutes.

[ar15barrels]

So, when can I throw a pistol grip on my AR?

As soon as we win in the US supreme court.
Don't hold your breath for anything solid in the next 5 years or so.

[CAsubject]

While Benitez's ruling was solid as usual, I don't understand giving California any "good" will with the stay. We only needed five minutes and a repeat of what happened with the mags.

[zuverza]

Benitez is Cuban... way way way way different mindset than our common Hispanic from Mexico...

What kind lf mindset is that? That Cubans have it all given to them because they live under commies? Political refugees?

Is this mindset different because they like black beans and mexicans like pinto beans?

Is your mindset that of a common hokie or redneck?

I love my firearms and the constitution that protects my capacity to own such machinery. But having to share the perception that im linked to intolerant xenophobes can feel just icky.

[The Gleam]

Because the deep-dive representatives of that demeanor are actually despot shills, and DON'T want it going this way.

Their motivation here is to type sweet "nothings" in our ears.

[guntrust]

http://guntrust.org

[The Gleam]

Yeah it seems cool but sadly this is going to do absolutely nothing. Scotus won't take the case, California doesn't care about ethics, or the constitution. Our governor is a one man government. People popping popcorn now are downright delusional.

It's not pessimism, it's realism. The 9th is anti gun and nothing has changed. Sure, a few wins here or there might squeak out but the "ultra rare" en banc will always pop up to crush them. It's going to be years before AWs are settled and even then, there's nothing to keep anti gun courts from just continuing to do what they want.

Not happy at all... It doesn't matter.. filthy rat bum commie judges will interfere...

This.

Unless the SCOTUS grows some balls, this ruling means f<?! all.

Some seem just a little too excited, maybe even ecstatic by their derisive-laden contemplation, and back it with vitriol.

Odd.

I'm all for "guarded optimism" as SWalt noted, and being realistic is one thing, whereby you do so to develop strategy; but gloating in a nihilistic sludge to the point of being damned near orgasmic when there is some conjecture and adversity in which to point, and go "AH HAH!" over it, makes me wonder of shills and losers that can't help themselves to do nothing but machinate with disdain, when something looks to be positive, even against further odds and hurdles.

Because they actually want it to be that way?

Why help perpetuate the other side's demeanor and agenda at all? Why KEEP returning to continue to denounce and push defeat?

What purpose does that empty cynicism serve?

[Transient]

Tag

You're it

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

[Transient]

While this is great news, the fight is not over. We have to keep hammering these bastards until they leave us alone.

And also, please do not wear an Orange Shirt! SD Mayor Super Cuck just asked people to wear orange to show their support for gun control! So F him and his crew!

I'm in SD. I'll wear a scary black featureless shirt with high capacity sleeves. It'll be tagless to scare all those hoplophobic estrogen-filled betas. Oh the number of nightmares that'll cause me to grin like a grinch stealing Christmas.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

[Transient]

A lot of us have been down this road before only to watch cases denied by the SCOTUS. Guarded optimism is how I would describe it. Now its just a waiting game. I have no doubt the stay will be in place until the 9th Circus issues a ruling. Until then I will just marvel at our luck of having the Honorable Judge Roger T. Benitez rule on this case.

I was in Highland Park, IL for the disappointing cert denial by SCOTUS in Friedman v Highland Park. I understand your pain.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

[curtisfong]

What purpose does that empty cynicism serve?

You really don't understand why people *naturally* expect the worst? It should be obvious to you.

[Transient]

"Because this case involves serious questions going to the merits, a temporary stay is in the public interest. This declaration and permanent injunction are stayed for 30 days during which time the Attorney General may appeal and seek a stay from the Court of Appeals."

We are being trolled.

To me this reads as Benitez saying, "Come at me, bro."

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk