Would you still buy gen 3 glocks if you can't buy gen 4 glocks?

[EGrove]

Now that there is no sse option to get a current gen model do you lose much improvement settling for gen 3.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Rhyyke]

Depends on the model I think but the difference isnt huge. I picked up a Gen 3 21SF and I haven't looked back.

[00Medic]

I hear mixed reviews of the Gen4 vs. the Gen3. I'll still get the few Gen3's I don't have yet but I do regret not getting the G41 when SSE was still around.

[oath-keeper]

I love my 4 G21 Gen 3's. Don't care for the adjustable blackstrap.

[Pupulepeter]

No, unless you have hands that are excessively small or large. IMHO, the interchangeable back-strap is one more thing to break or lose in the long run. I prefer the Gen 3 pistols.

[Mr.Caketown]

Not that I would ever buy a glock , but if I did I would get a Gen 3 over the Gen4 because the grip on the 3 fits my little girl hands better than the Gen 4 G17

[stix213]

I have small hands, but I haven't found the Gen 3's to have size issues (any more than any other handgun I suppose). I own 3 Gen 3's.

I would though like to get Gen 4's in the future since years from now it will be easier to get upgrades, replacement parts, and 3rd party components for Gen 4's, like how it is easier today to get stuff for the Gen 3's than Gen 2's.

Also if I were a left handed shooter I'd prefer the Gen 4's most likely.

[BoJackUSMC]

Prefer gen 4, grip texture....however, I am a sig p320 guy.

[meno377]

Yes, but my favorite is the RTF2 versions. Great Texture.

[Beetle Bailey]

Do not need the adjustable backstraps, so I actually prefer gen 3 anyways. Plan to pick up a G19, G20SF, and G30SF.

[WASR10]

I prefer Gen 3's.

[Octaviob]

Not for a 40-50% markup. The gen 3's are fine.

[GW]

No, unless you have hands that are excessively small or large. IMHO, the interchangeable back-strap is one more thing to break or lose in the long run. I prefer the Gen 3 pistols.

Plus 1
The adjustable backstrap just wasn't a selling point to me.
I am quite happy with my Gen 3's

[JDW67]

All my Glocks are Gen 4's. I sold my Gen 3s last year to convert over to Gen 4's. I prefer the texture and slightly smaller grip.

edit: Yes, I would get the Gen 3 if the Gen 4 was not available.

[lakersfan]

Yes. I got a Gen 3 G17. I'd like a Gen 4 though. Better texture on the grip, dual recoil spring, larger mag release and I would use one of the backstraps and modify it with fiberglass or something to get rid of the hump on the grip.

[BisDak]

Yes.

Both pistols I regret selling.

G19. G30sf.


.

[dvs762]

I still have a Gen2 G17 I use...works fine and its all beat to crap..a Gen3 would be fine with me...I have read about people having issues with Gen4 Glocks...In fact I will be looking for a G17 Gen3 pretty soon here..

[oddjob]

yes

[MrExel17]

Yes, would still and have been buying Gen 3s

[jdben92883]

I wouldn't buy an unreliable Gen 4. I've READ about all kinds of people having issues with Gen 4's.

Oh wait...I own about a dozen Gen 4's and all have been flawless.

You can always PPT one, but I wouldn't pay more than $700.

[SkyHawk]

A lot of people don't realize that all Gen 4 Glocks are Short Frame (SF) when used without the backstrap. This is a pretty big deal for some people with small to medium hands because the reach to the trigger is shorter than a standard Gen 3 for a given model.

You can get some Gen 3 SF Glocks but not the popular ones like 19/26/17/23. I wouldn't hesitate to buy a Gen 3 and I own two in the form of a G30S and G22, but all my other Glocks are Gen 4 and I am happy for that. All the pistols on my permit currently are Gen 4 Glocks.

[steel30]

Bought one today from a Calgunner! Thanks! G19 Gen3 with lots of goodies...

[BigL]

Personal preference but I think Gen3's are better than Gen4's.

I don't like the dual recoil setup.

[Crysknife1013]

My answer would be an emphatic "Hell to the yes!" :yes:

Yes, but my favorite is the RTF2 versions. Great Texture.
I like your style brother! RTF2 is my preferance too.

[Lead Waster]

I think for the .40 S&W Glocks, the gen4's dual spring made a difference, but in 9mm, it didn't.

Gen3 is fine, aside from what I mentioned, you won't really notice a difference.

[nick]

Yes. In fact, i intend to, as I still get my GSSF coupons.

[bshot]

No, unless you have hands that are excessively small or large. IMHO, the interchangeable back-strap is one more thing to break or lose in the long run. I prefer the Gen 3 pistols.

Just curious, how many incidents has a back-strap break or get lose?

It can happen, but I think it is unlikely.

[SimonBirch]

Having owned both gens, I prefer gen 3s. Don't really care for the removable back straps and the ambi mag release

[MA5177]

I like the gen 4 but also have no issues with the gen 3, I have med to large hands ( and visable abs) but on my 4 I like it without the backstraps and a talon wrap around grip. Same with my 3's

[Bruce]

I'd buy Gen 3's. I don't like the feel of the little bumps on the Gen 4 grip.

[vintagearms]

I sold both my Gen4's, not for profit (basically my cost) and dont regret it. Other than the better backstrap, the additional recoil (its not pronounced but noticible for those that shoot Glock's alot) and the issues with the extractors, the tradeoff to the Gen 3 wasn't worth it to me.

[Wild West]

Now that there is no sse option to get a current gen model do you lose much improvement settling for gen 3.


Key word "SETTLING".

Isn't Kalifornia an amazing state!! :facepalm:

[Cedone12]

To me it doesn't matter really. The only Gen 4 i've tried is the 42 and its ok. The rest I have are Gen 3's. If the prices come down a little more in the Gen 4's Ill consider it, but I'm ok shooting Gen 3's for now. In my opinion, companies will eventually stop making aftermarket parts for the Gen 3 as more generations come out, but I'll cross that bridge when i get there.

[SkyHawk]

To me it doesn't matter really. The only Gen 4 i've tried is the 42 and its ok.

The G42 is not Gen 4.You will note that Glock does not call it Gen 4, and Gen 4 does not appear on the slide. Since it is a new type of pistol from Glock, maybe it is Gen 1.

[BoJackUSMC]

Yes, i don't think glock 42 is gen 4. My glock 42 slide does not have gen 4 label imprinted on it.

[Sputnik]

I don't really see much of a choice for most people if they want a Glock in Calif.
I only have one plastic gun, a 21SF, and I don't see anything wrong with it besides being plastic. If I were to want another I don't see why a gen 3 would be a bad thing. If we were in AZ I'm sure I'd just look for the better price.

[iMigraine]

I really like my Gen4 G34 since I have large hands and shoot left-handed. The reason I went for the Gen4 was the double recoil spring (longer life), large mag release and back straps. Happen to really like the beaver tail back strap. Also going SSE was another way to say FU to the stupid CA handgun laws.

My only complaint is the finger molded hand grip which feel less form fitting for my hand. I also have a Gen4 G35 but actually plan to sell because I'm not really digging .40 cal that much.

[Mossy Man]

Gen 3 is fine and I'm ok with having only those

that being said, i'm not okay with the state telling me i can't have a gen 4.

[rmatt]

gladly as i prefer the 3rd gen to the gen4

[bizarrocolin]

I really want a g40...other than that, I wouldn't give up my Gen 3 20 and 29.

[deckhandmike]

Ugh, being a lefty with swollen, tore up hands I would love a gen 4.

[bsg]

Gen 3 is fine; my preference is Gen 2.

[Area 52]

Nothing awful about the gen 3's, but any time I see a RTF2 I snap that baby up.

[stormvet]

I prefer the gen 4's, but there is nothing wrong with the 3's I own 5 of them.

[longrifle1]

Love the Gen 3. Well proven, ultra reliable. I plan on buying a few more.

[hermosabeach]

I never saw the need for Gen 4

Does anyone use any back strap other than the one that is the same size as the Gen 3?

The old recoil spring works just fine....

no big deal....

[Bubba_Leon]

I prefer Gen 3's.
You beat me to it. Given the apples to apples choice I'd take a gen 3

[axhoaxho]

I have Gen 2/3/4 Glock's.

I have regular-size hands, and I am right-handed. Between my Gen 3 and Gen 4 -- I could hardly feel the differences, and I shot them both equally well.

Sure, I wouldn't mind to have the Gen 4 just because, but in California here the Gen 3 is fine by me.

[Packy14]

Now that there is no sse option to get a current gen model do you lose much improvement settling for gen 3.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

I prefer Gen4 due to feel and I dig the HK style double recoil spring... Especially in >9mm calibers. Mostly I like the Beavers.

[lakersfan]

I have to change my grip on my G17 Gen3 in order to reach the mag release. The Gen4 looks like it would solve that issue.

[ap3572001]

I still have GEN 3 in my duty holster, own GEN2/3/4 and like them all. My facorite is my G19 GEN2.

[CodyGT46]

3rd and 4th gen? Heck I'm still rocking a Gen 2 G19!

[SB1964]

I bought my first Glock in the early 90's. I've never shot or even thought about buying a gen 4. I love a nice beaver!

[knk113]

I purchased Gen3 G19 last year as brand new. Initially I planned to pick up G26 but as soon as G19 fitted my hand like condom I bought it. I would still pick my Gen3 over Gen4 despite the fact I am left handed shooter and G4 can switch mag release...

[Cedone12]

The G42 is not Gen 4.You will note that Glock does not call it Gen 4, and Gen 4 does not appear on the slide. Since it is a new type of pistol from Glock, maybe it is Gen 1.

Thanks for the education! I never really paid attention, which I should. I just assumed that with the duel recoil spring bumped it up to a GEN 4 version.

Also, I think I quickly read somewhere that Gen 3 sub compacts have duel springs?

[itsmekevin]

Even when we had SSE, I still preferred and continued purchasing Gen 3's.

[ElDub1950]

I've had Gen 3s for awhile. Bought a Gen 4 G34 last year and like it a lot. But still bought a Gen 3 G17 last month and DROSing a Gen 3 G26 tomorrow.

So, I guess, No, not being able to buy new Gen 4s doesn't really matter to me.

[ElDub1950]

The G42 is not Gen 4.You will note that Glock does not call it Gen 4, and Gen 4 does not appear on the slide. Since it is a new type of pistol from Glock, maybe it is Gen 1.

Kind of interesting that the new G42 & G43 and not Gen 4, but the new G40 and G41 are.

Then there's the G24 which is a .40 cal version of the G17L, but they didn't call it the G22L. And neither of them are referred to as Gen 3 or Gen 4.

[duc71]

IMO not thing much diff between gen3 and 4, just the proudy off list fancy make the gen 4 cost more for the $ LOL. I perfer the less $ the better. Just my 2 cents :)

[Dr.Lou]

[QUOTE=Beetle Bailey;16228794]Do not need the adjustable backstraps, so I actually prefer gen 3 anyways. /QUOTE]
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Same here!!!

[The War Wagon]

Uhmmm... no. :rolleyes:




http://i212.photobucket.com/albums/cc305/The_War_Wagon/howaglockworks.gif

[Bill Steele]

I like my Gen 3 Glocks but prefer my Gen 4 Glocks. Now that the Gen 4's are off the table, if I wanted a new Glock, wouldn't hesitate to buy a Gen 3.

[EGrove]

I was told gen 4 glocks have dual springs and have better recoil. You guys shoot better with gen 4?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[ElDub1950]

I have Gen 3s and Gen 4s but don't have a 3 & 4 in the same model. I think it would be awfully hard to detect a difference just because of the recoil spring.

[SkyHawk]

Also, I think I quickly read somewhere that Gen 3 sub compacts have duel springs?

Yep you heard right - the Gen 3 Glock 26 and 27 have dual recoil springs. I had a Gen 3 27 but sold it after I got a Gen 4 G26. I shoot the 26 much better, that 27 was a handful in .40SW :) Believe it or not my sister in law carries the Gen 3 G27 as her CCW pistol, she has for years.

[Che762x39]

Nothing wrong with a Gen 1 Glock 17. A Glock is a Glock. :oji:

[EGrove]

I've seen slow mo recoil videos of hickock45...gen 4 glock clearly had less recoil in 40 cal. Also he stated gen 4 glock had a better trigger.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[gsparesa]

Duel recoil springs did not come out on gen 4 Glocks. Dual recoil springs are on the G30sf gen 3.

[Wordupmybrotha]

Gen 3 has proven reliability.

[CK_32]

I own both and still don't care which im holding.


They are all Glocks to me. I'd take either happily.

[Wallabing]

Yes, Gen 3 is perfect, better than gen 4.

Gen 3 is a classic design for the ages.

[Rhyyke]

I looked at a Gen 4 when SSE was around, but decided my slot was better used on something else. Picked up a Gen 3 21SF and have no regrets.

[EGrove]

Yes, Gen 3 is perfect, better than gen 4.



Gen 3 is a classic design for the ages.


Care to elaborate? Isn't the dual spring found on gen 4 an improvement?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Wallabing]

Care to elaborate? Isn't the dual spring found on gen 4 an improvement?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

The gen 3 recoil spring for full size worked for all calibers
The gen 3 recoil spring for subcompact worked for all calibers

Now glock has switched over the the dual recoil spring system, each different caliber and size glock needs it's specific tension spring, so interchangability was lost.

[Wallabing]

The gen 4 disconnect and ejector housing are different aswell, so that kills interchangability aswell.

[jsigone]

Don't care for the gen, but I'd take a fde 17 for $500 please :53:

[DerekAztec]

In about 7 months we will only be able to get the GEN 0

[Gaius Marius]

I was actually hoping that Gen 3 prices would go down during SSE as I had zero interst in a Gen 4. I was also hoping Gen 3 prices would drop now that the 4's have reached adequate production numbers, but again, no dice. Based on my experience with both, I would still rather have a 3 than a 4 if it was 9mm or .45, though I would say a .40 or 10mm might be better in 4 due to the buffer. I know most of what is driving it is the "latest and greatest" syndrome versus practicality.

[626Tony]

id still buy gen 2 glocks

[EGrove]

Anyone want to talk me out of buying a gen 3 glock 35 with a 9mm conversion barrel?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[ElDub1950]

Anyone want to talk me out of buying a gen 3 glock 35 with a 9mm conversion barrel?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

No objections here. I've had a G23 and G27 with 9mm conversions for quite awhile. It's a great way to go. Selling the 27 but definitely keeping the 23.

[nbirnbaum2]

I have a Glock 21sf, g19, and g36. all gen 3. That being said,for the insane amount being asked in CA to legally get a gen 4 you can get a very nice sig, or even an HK.

I would recommend looking at a Sig SP2022, I got my sister one as it has the removable back straps, like the gen 4 and is on roster. Great gun... that is if da/sa is ok with you.

[Whatthepho?]

I prefer gen3 rtf2. Got a vickers glock

[Whatthepho?]

Anyone want to talk me out of buying a gen 3 glock 35 with a 9mm conversion barrel?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

35s are awesome for competition. Well the .40 is for power factor.

[BigPimping]

The extra cost of Gen 4 is not justified by what you receive. With that said, I prefer my Gen2 G17 over my Gen 3 G17. Both are wonderful and now I must have a Gen 1.

[YCBAPAYL]

Same stuff minor differences