Originally Posted by Crom

OP, I don't understand what you're asking... But if it helps you here is my take on Peruta.

The Peruta court is correct because it took direction from Heller and McDonald and adopted the exact same 2-step inquiry to resolve the Second Amendment claim. In plain English, the court said

Originally Posted by Al Norris

While the response is overall pretty good, Mr. Cooper has taken the liberty of undermining Alan Gura's argument in Kachalsky by claiming that there is no circuit split.

Originally Posted by 7.62x63mmUS

Just wait until Obama's 2nd term. You'll see federal agencies doing whatever the hell they damn well please.