PDA

View Full Version : Hypothetical situation: Car theft


YZINGERR
06-08-2009, 10:34 PM
I was thinking about the legality of my thoughts so here it is.

Simply put, if I awoke to find someone jimmy-ing my car door in my driveway, could I shoot this person with less than lethal projectiles (i.e. bean bag or rubber bullets)?

What would be the repercussion of my actions?
Im sure "discharging a firearm in public" would be one?!?
I am in the San francisco Bay area of CA
http://static.alstechnologies.com/images/products/cement/300/ALS1202.jpg

ST5MF
06-08-2009, 10:45 PM
I was thinking about the legality of my thoughts so here it is.

Simply put, if I awoke to find someone jimmy-ing my car door in my driveway, could I shoot this person with less than lethal projectiles (i.e. bean bag or rubber bullets)?

What would be the repercussion of my actions?
Im sure "discharging a firearm in public" would be one?!?


This ain't TX.

The only smart thing to do is call the PO-PO to report your car stolen.

Maybe get a description of the guy(?).

To provoke conflict when you or a third party are in no immediate mortal danger can potentially be more damaging to you in more ways than you care to imagine.

Say you shoot your non-lethal only to have him or his "shadow" return fire with a "NOT SO NON-LETHAL."

REMEMBER: This is California Bro- if the crooks don't get you the law will...

YZINGERR
06-08-2009, 10:49 PM
REMEMBER: This is California Bro- if the crooks don't get you the law will...
You make a good point.
I realize that CA is for the criminals, I was just wondering..
I would not be stupid enough to have the shotgun be a condom dispenser, it would undoubtedly be followed up by 00 buck.

ST5MF
06-08-2009, 11:14 PM
You make a good point.
I realize that CA is for the criminals, I was just wondering..
I would be stupid enough to have the shotgun be a condom dispenser, it would undoubtedly be followed up by 00 buck.

I am sure you mean "NOT STUPID" enough. Again this is CALI- You launch those 00 buck rounds without being in any mortal danger and kill the scumbag or anyone else you are probably going to do time in the pokey.

NOT WORTH IT! Not over a "car" any "CAR."

YZINGERR
06-08-2009, 11:17 PM
of course, that is why this is hypothetical!
You cant even shoot a bad PERSON in your own home without severe repercussions and fear of jail time/ lawsuit!!

ST5MF
06-08-2009, 11:23 PM
of course, that is why this is hypothetical!
You cant even shoot a bad PERSON in your own home without severe repercussions and fear of jail time/ lawsuit!!

"Tactically" if you don't have back-ups with "lethal" devices then a non-lethal device is JUST PLAIN STUPID.

SVT-40
06-08-2009, 11:26 PM
I was thinking about the legality of my thoughts so here it is.

Simply put, if I awoke to find someone jimmy-ing my car door in my driveway, could I shoot this person with less than lethal projectiles (i.e. bean bag or rubber bullets)?

What would be the repercussion of my actions?
Im sure "discharging a firearm in public" would be one?!?
I am in the San francisco Bay area of CA
http://static.alstechnologies.com/images/products/cement/300/ALS1202.jpg

In a word. NO. You cannot use a weapon like this to stop someone form breaking into your car. Just like the cops would not be justified in the same way.

Actually the correct term used now for these projectiles is "less lethal". The term "less than lethal" went out of use when some folks died from getting shot by these type rounds.

Illegal discharge could be a problem as well as ADW.

Even though the scumbag was trying to break into your car. It does not justify excessive force.

Get on your cell and call the PD. don't let the scum know you know he's there give good info to the PD so you can I'D. the felon later. Or make a lot of noise and turn on some lights. It will certainly scare him away.

El Gato
06-08-2009, 11:26 PM
No...
try "commonwealth vs emmons"...1943 is the year if I am not mistaken... and less than lethal means it is sometimes lethal...

take your gun with you to arrest said miscreant... surely... shoot him out of hand?
No...

tyrist
06-09-2009, 7:32 PM
Nope and if you kill him with it your going to prison. Bean bag rounds are for aggressive/combative suspects not thieves.

BigDogatPlay
06-09-2009, 7:56 PM
Locked up for ADW with a firearm almost certainly.... some enterprising DA with an axe to grind might go so far as to charge attempt 187.

Wouldn't go there with those rounds, or any kind of round on a property crime.

Ron-Solo
06-09-2009, 9:00 PM
They are "less lethal, NOT non-lethal.

Don't do it!